Casee LogoCasee.ioBlog
Back to AppLogin
Skip to main content

How to Respond When Customer Receives Used Item Instead of New (Email Template)

· 6 min read

When customers order new products but receive obviously used or returned items, they feel scammed. This guide shows you how to apologize sincerely, offer immediate replacement plus compensation, and investigate your fulfillment process.

Example Customer Complaint​

Subject: Received USED product - supposed to be new!

Hi,

I ordered a "NEW" Instant Pot from your website (Order #81245) and 
received it today. When I opened the box, it's clearly been used before:

- The box was damaged and re-taped
- There are food stains inside the pot
- The manual is missing
- The packaging materials are wrinkled and look repacked

I paid $119 for a NEW item, not someone's return. This is completely 
unacceptable and honestly feels like a scam.

I want a BRAND NEW, unopened Instant Pot shipped to me immediately 
with a prepaid return label for this used one. Or give me a full 
refund plus compensation for wasting my time.

Very angry,
Robert

Casee.io Analysis: Automatic Case Classification​

When you paste Robert's message into Casee.io, the AI instantly analyzes and categorizes the case:

📋 Case Summary:

  • Regarding: Received a used product instead of new
  • Priority: High
  • Categories: Wrong Item Received, Damaged Item, Product Quality

Key Issues Identified​

Casee.io breaks down the complaint into 2 specific issues that need addressing:

Issue 1: Clear Evidence of Used Item​

Customer's concern:

"When I opened the box, it's clearly been used before: - The box was damaged and re-taped - There are food stains inside the pot - The manual is missing - The packaging materials are wrinkled and look repacked"

Suggested response:

I understand you received an Instant Pot that shows clear signs of previous use, including a damaged box, food stains, a missing manual, and repacked materials. I sincerely apologize for this unacceptable situation. You expected a new product, and we failed to deliver that.

Issue 2: Demand for Resolution (Replacement or Refund + Compensation)​

Customer's concern:

"I want a BRAND NEW, unopened Instant Pot shipped to me immediately with a prepaid return label for this used one. Or give me a full refund plus compensation for wasting my time."

Suggested response:

I see you're requesting either a brand new, unopened Instant Pot shipped immediately with a prepaid return label for the used item, or a full refund along with compensation for your time. I want to assure you that we will make this right for you.

Complete Email Response​

Casee.io also generates opening and closing paragraphs to frame your response:

Opening (AI-Generated):​

Hi Robert,

I'm so sorry to hear about the issue with your recent Instant Pot order 
(Order #81245). It's completely understandable that you're upset, and I 
sincerely apologize that you received a product that appears to have 
been used instead of a brand new one. This is definitely not the 
experience we want for our customers.

Body (Combine Issue Responses):​

You can now copy and paste each suggested response, editing as needed to add specific replacement shipping details and compensation offers.

Closing (AI-Generated):​

We appreciate your patience and understanding as we work to resolve 
this for you. We'll be in touch shortly with the next steps.

Sincerely,
[Your Name/Company Name]

Why This Approach Works​

✅ Validates specific evidence - Food stains, re-taped box, missing manual

✅ Doesn't gaslight customer - No "are you sure?" questions

✅ Acknowledges severity - "Unacceptable," "feels like a scam"

✅ Offers both options - Replacement or refund, customer chooses

✅ Promises compensation - Beyond just fixing the immediate problem

Resolution Options with Compensation​

Option A: Rush replacement + compensation (Recommended)​

I'm shipping a brand new, sealed Instant Pot to you via overnight 
delivery at no charge. It will arrive by [specific date]. I've also 
applied a $30 credit to your account as an apology for this experience. 
A prepaid return label for the used item is attached to this email.

Option B: Full refund + discount on future purchase​

I've processed a full refund of $119 to your original payment method. 
You should see it within 3-5 business days. Additionally, I'm sending 
you a 25% off code (APOLOGY25) valid for any purchase in the next 90 
days. Please keep the used Instant Pot—no need to return it.

Option C: Replacement + partial refund​

I'm sending a brand new Instant Pot with expedited shipping. I've also 
refunded you $40 (33% of purchase price) for the inconvenience. You'll 
receive both the replacement AND keep the money. Return label attached 
for the used item.

Option D: Full refund + keep item​

I've processed your full $119 refund immediately. You can keep the used 
Instant Pot or donate it—no need to return. We take full responsibility 
for this error and want to make it as painless as possible for you.

How to Use Casee.io for Used Item Complaints​

  1. Paste the customer's message into Casee.io
  2. Review the analysis - Check specific condition issues mentioned
  3. Copy suggested responses - Use the itemized responses for each concern
  4. Add resolution details - Replacement tracking, refund amount, compensation
  5. Follow up internally - Investigate how used item entered new inventory

Critical Investigation Steps​

URGENT - Complete immediately:

  1. Pull warehouse records - Was this a customer return?
  2. Check SKU history - Does this item have return/restock notes?
  3. Review photos - If customer sent evidence, document it
  4. Identify source - Was it sold as "open box" by mistake?
  5. Check other orders - Are similar complaints happening?
  6. Inspect inventory - Any other returned items in "new" stock?

Root Cause Analysis​

Common reasons used items get sold as new:

  • Restocking errors - Returns put back in new inventory
  • Inadequate inspection - Returned items not properly examined
  • SKU confusion - "Open box" and "new" SKUs mixed up
  • Warehouse shortcuts - Pressure to process returns quickly
  • Third-party sellers - Marketplace sellers listing condition incorrectly
  • Missing QC step - No verification before re-shelving returns

Prevent Future Incidents​

Implement these controls:

  • Separate return area - Physically isolated from new inventory
  • Return inspection checklist - Document condition before restocking
  • Different SKUs - New vs open-box vs refurbished get unique codes
  • Quarantine period - Returns held 24-48 hours before restock evaluation
  • Manager approval - Supervisor must approve return-to-stock decisions
  • Customer photos - Document condition when processing returns

Quality Control:

  • Random audits - Sample "new" inventory for used items
  • Barcode scanning - Reject returns-SKU from new inventory bins
  • Packing slip verification - Cross-check SKU before shipping
  • Sealed packaging - Manufacturer-sealed items only in "new" stock

Important:

  • Never argue - Customer evidence (food stains) is clear
  • Act immediately - Delays look like you're hiding something
  • Overcompensate - Costs less than negative reviews/chargebacks
  • Document everything - Photos, emails, resolution for records
  • Follow up - Confirm customer received replacement and is satisfied

Prevent reviews:

  • Strong resolution often prevents negative reviews
  • Generous compensation shows good faith
  • Fast action demonstrates you care
  • Ask if issue is resolved before closing ticket

Try It Yourself​

Want to handle used item complaints faster and protect your reputation? Try Casee.io free →

Paste your customer message and get instant analysis with damage-control, compensation-focused response suggestions.